Exegetical Brief: 2 Thessalonians 3:6,14,15 - Admonish Him As a Brother

Abstract

John F. Brug examines 2 Thessalonians 3:6,14,15 to clarify whether Paul’s instructions refer to a partial or complete break of fellowship with an impenitent Christian. Brug analyzes the Greek terms and context, concluding that Paul commands a full separation from disorderly individuals, not a probationary suspension. He argues that the phrase “admonish him as a brother” reflects the congregation’s loving intent to restore the offender, not his continued status within the fellowship. Brug compares this passage with others on church discipline (e.g., Matthew 18, Romans 16, Titus 3), showing consistent two-step procedures: admonition followed by separation. He also addresses historical misunderstandings between WELS and CLC, noting that differing interpretations of this passage do not imply doctrinal disagreement. Brug emphasizes that excommunication, though a law-based act, is carried out with evangelical purpose—to regain the lost brother. —Abstract prepared by Microsoft Copilot (GPT-4)