"Smells Like Pietism" Comparing Pietistic Conventicles to Modern Lutheran Small Groups

Abstract

Pietism has been criticized throughout history and one of the main reasons is its use of conventicles. However, there is a growing trend within the Wisconsin Evangelical Lutheran Synod (WELS) where congregations are starting lay led small groups to retain membership and foster closer relationships. Some argue that this practice is too similar to conventicles and therefore unscriptural or dangerous. This thesis aims to compare Pietistic conventicles to modern small group practices, acknowledging their similarities and differences. In conclusion, I will demonstrate that Pietism can be avoided in small group practices. I will offer a few opinions on why labeling all small groups as Pietistic is an overreaction.