The Helenville Problem

Abstract

This historical study investigates the circumstances behind Pastor Gottlieb Reim’s resignation as president of the Wisconsin Synod in 1865, a mystery briefly noted in Koehler’s history as “trouble at Helenville.” Reim, a staunch confessional leader and organizer of congregations, faced an unexpected scandal during his pastorate at St. Peter’s, Helenville. Church records reveal that false accusations by a member, Mrs. Wolfmeier, led to a formal investigation by the congregation and ministerium. Though Reim was exonerated and declared innocent by synod, lingering doubts and concern for the ministry’s reputation prompted him to accept a call to Beaver Dam and request temporary release from synodical membership. The essay concludes that Reim sacrificed personal advancement for the sake of consciences and the church’s integrity, later continuing his ministry in Minnesota until his death in 1882. —Abstract prepared by Microsoft Copilot (GPT‑4)